Category Archives: Security

African Veterans of WWII

The BBC celebrates Africa’s forgotten wartime heroes for VJ Day.

The contribution of West Africans was played down in official versions of the Allied war in Asia, and until now, few have had an opportunity to tell their tale.

In fact, only two in 10 of the soldiers who fought in Burma were white.

The article tells a story of a soldier who was forced by the British to join the military at age 16. His name also was changed by the colonialists to “African Banana”.

The article suggests that men like this were dispersed and then ignored after victory rather than given opportunities to build upon their expertise. I suspect this had two negative consequences. First, it probably reduced the capacity of Allied forces to engage in jungle combat in subsequent conflicts.

They were central to the push to clear Japanese forces out of the jungle and mountain ranges of Burma, from where they threatened British India.

This was achieved through a gruelling campaign of jungle marches, battles and ambushes, in which supplies were delivered entirely by air.

Usman Katsina remembers it well.

“Everything that was meant to be used – your food, your clothes, everything – was given to you and you were required to carry it, on your head and back. Some even died from exhaustion, from travelling long distances, with a heavy load,” he says.

[…]

Their enemy was an extremely dangerous opponent. Japanese soldiers were trained well in the art of jungle warfare, where the first rule was concealment.

It was a skill the Nigerian troops had to learn too.

“The Japanese in the jungle were just like snakes – they hid before you could see them, it was very hard,” recalls 97-year-old Hassan Sokoto.

Elite veterans of the Fourteenth Army and Burma campaign were soon being integrated back into their home countries rather than given opportunities to lead future combat. It makes me wonder whether the struggles faced by French forces in Indochina and soon after by the Americans in Korea and Vietnam could have had a better start, let alone outcome. Although health precautions and research into hygiene and tropical medicine was shared among allies (e.g. jeep-based ambulances, forward surgical teams, light air evacuations) experience from the 1944 campaign of the Chindits, led by Major General Orde Wingate, appears to have been downplayed or erased altogether.

Second, the return of the African veterans to their home sowed seeds of discontent among men who had served as equals or more during the war. The experience of the men who successfully organized and fought in North Africa and Asia was inevitably going to change their perceptions at home. They expected the same or similar respect as any soldier under the British War Office. This threatened the British Colonial Office authority and opened a rift in policy towards equality at home.

The role of Indians and Gurkhas is known. But when Allied commander General William Slim thanked his 14th army at the end of the campaign, he did not even mention the Africans.

[…]

Despite the hierarchy, the war in Burma played some part in breaking down the race barriers of the era.

“Initially I saw the white man as someone better than me. But after the war, I considered him an equal,” recalls former infantryman Dauda Kafanchan.

In post-war Nigeria, the colonial government gave some veterans land to begin new lives as farmers. The project was also a scheme to reduce their potential impact as a new political force.

The decline of British power combined with the rise in expertise and experience of Africans during the war accelerated a drive for independence from colonial rule. Independence of India was a sign of events to come. The British would have been wise to invest in this sea of change rather than obstruct or try to deny it, as recounted in the story of an angry Gurkha in the book “Quartered Safe Out Here” by George MacDonald Fraser

We were talking politics, and a clever and articulate Congress party supporter, who happened to be extremely swarthy, got very emotional. “You British,” he cried, “with the help of this type of people — “here he indicated Thapa [a Gurkha] and a couple of Sikhs “–have been exploiting this land for centuries! You have bled India white!”

One of the Sikhs murmered behind his gin and tonic: “It hasn’t had much visible effect on you.” which was well below the belt, but it might have passed if the Nigerian hadn’t laughed fit to rattle the chandelier.

Accepting the change and managing through diversity would have not only increased the chance of secure and stable growth in many nations but also possibly allowed the British to reposition themselves and benefit even under new regimes. Instead, a vacuum was formed in occupied nations during their administration and following withdrawal by the British that led soon to civil conflict and war. With luck the United States will work to avoid the same mistakes in their transition plans for Iraq and Afghanistan.

US Kills Afghan Civilians

The AP reports that a false positive led to a US attack on innocent civilians in Afghanistan:

An American bombing that killed up to 90 Afghan civilians last month was based on false information provided by a rival tribe and did not kill a single Taliban fighter, the president’s spokesman said Sunday.

The claim contradicted a U.S. contention that the Aug. 22 raid on the western village of Azizabad killed up to 35 Taliban fighters.

Although the new more sophisticated campaigns are a big improvement over prior years of conventional warfare they are not without serious risk. It should be obvious that to make progress, intelligence gathering has to be able to factor in social issues such as rivalries and politics in order to determine military targets and potential for “blow back”.

I am reminded of this again today, when looking at first-person photographs of the US bombing campaign in Somalia:

People walk through rubble after U.S. war planes killed an Islamist rebel said to be al Qaeda’s leader in Somalia and as many as 30 other people in Dusamareb, May 1, 2008. REUTERS/Abdi Guled

Information integrity is a cornerstone of intelligence-based warfare. A related problem, I have noticed recently, is pressure in American politics by those who say they are defiant and suspicious of “highly-educated” people and anyone who presents a data or fact-based approach to problems. I think some Americans approach food in a way that is an apt metaphor for their military and political strategy:

We fry things nobody ever considered friable – things like cupcakes, banana sandwiches and batter dipped artificial cheese…even pickles.

Fire, ready, aim. Did I lose the good with the bad? Civilians? Facts? Unfortunate. Fry again.

Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska said that Palin and other critics were not helping the GOP by tossing out false claims. Portions of the Democratic health care bills “are bad enough that we don’t need to be making things up,” Murkowski said, invoking a phrase that Palin used in her resignation speech, when she asked the news media to “quit making things up.”

This is not to condemn firing or frying, but to say that both need to be handled with care and a focus on outcomes or they may makes things worse than what existed before. At this point I feel like taking this story into a historical reference to the Maginot-line but perhaps that will be a post for another day.

WordPress Flaw

Annoying? Yes, a URL flaw in the WordPress password reset should be on many to-do lists for today:

…a specially crafted URL could be requested that would allow an attacker to bypass a security check to verify a user requested a password reset. As a result, the first account without a key in the database (usually the admin account) would have its password reset and a new password would be emailed to the account owner. This doesn’t allow remote access, but it is very annoying.

Patch, patch, patch…

Edited to add: 11 Tips to Secure WordPress